DeepSeek: Genius or Cheater? The Debate on AI Transparency & Data Practices
Is DeepSeek a cheater or a genius? Should OpenAI be held accountable for its data practices? Dive into this post as we break down the debate on AI transparency, data ethics, and the future of AI technology. Share your thoughts in the comments! š


DeepSeek vs. OpenAI: The AI War Heating Up (Whoās Stealing Whose Tech?)
The world of artificial intelligence (AI) is never short of drama, but the latest feud between DeepSeek (a Chinese AI company) and OpenAI (the creator of ChatGPT) is turning into a full-blown tech thriller. Accusations of stolen data, free models crushing paid ones, and even stock market chaosāletās break it all down in simple terms.
1. Whatās the Fight About?
The Rise of DeepSeekās āR1ā Model
DeepSeek recently launched a powerful AI model called R1, claiming it outperforms OpenAIās GPT-4o by a huge margin. The twist? R1 is free, while OpenAI charges $20/month for its premium model. This has sent shockwaves through the AI industry.
Why It Matters:
- Cost Advantage: Free tools like R1 could disrupt OpenAIās business model, especially for budget-conscious users.
- Market Panic: The U.S. stock market dipped briefly, with fears that investors might shift focus to cheaper AI solutions like DeepSeek.
2. The Big Accusation: Did DeepSeek Steal OpenAIās Tech?
OpenAI and some Indian companies are accusing DeepSeek of cheating. Hereās why:
The āDistillationā Controversy
- Whatās Distillation?: In AI, ādistillationā means using a powerful model (like OpenAIās GPT-4) to train a smaller, cheaper model (like DeepSeekās R1). Think of it as a student learning from a teacherās notes.
- OpenAIās Rules: Their terms of service forbid using GPT-4ās outputs to train rival models. OpenAI claims DeepSeek broke this rule.
The Smoking Gun: Reddit Screenshots
A Reddit thread went viral when users noticed something odd. When asked, āWho made you?ā, DeepSeekās AI sometimes replied:
- āIām ChatGPT by OpenAI.ā
- Other times, it said: āDeepSeek.ā


Screenshots of these conflicting answers sparked rumors that DeepSeek copied ChatGPTās code or data.
3. Irony Alert: OpenAI is ALSO Accused of Stealing!
While OpenAI points fingers at DeepSeek, Indian media giants like Reliance and Adani are suing OpenAI for the same reason. They claim:
- āOpenAI scraped our copyrighted news articles, videos, and data without permission to train GPT-4!ā
The Hypocrisy:
- OpenAI calls DeepSeek a āthiefā but faces identical accusations.
- Critics argue: āIf stealing data is wrong, why did OpenAI do it first?ā
4. How Did DeepSeek Respond?
DeepSeek isnāt hiding. Theyāve:
- Open-sourced their model (shared the code publicly).
- Published research papers explaining how R1 works.
Their Argument:
- āEven if we used some public data, we improved it. Innovation isnāt about reinventing the wheelāitās about building better wheels.ā
5. Why This Fight Matters for AIās Future
A Wake-Up Call for OpenAI
Sam Altman (OpenAIās CEO) once mocked Indian engineers, saying:
- āYouād need $10 billion to compete with us.ā
But DeepSeekās free R1 model proves small teams can challenge giants.
Chinaās AI Ambitions
China isnāt backing down. Models like Kimi 1.5 (from Alibaba) are already beating OpenAI in coding and math benchmarks. This signals a heated U.S.-China AI race.
6. What Happens Next?
- Investigations: OpenAI is probing whether DeepSeek illegally used its data.
- Lawsuits: Indian companies are pushing for compensation from OpenAI.
- Market Shakeup: Free models like R1 could force OpenAI to lower prices or innovate faster.
FAQ: Your Questions Answered
Q: Is DeepSeekās R1 really better than GPT-4?
A: In some tasks (like math and coding), yes. But GPT-4 still leads in creativity and general knowledge.
Q: Can I trust free AI models?
A: Theyāre great for basic tasks, but paid models like GPT-4 offer more reliability and advanced features.
Q: Whoās winning the AI race?
A: Itās too early to say! The U.S. has OpenAI, but China is catching up fast with models like DeepSeek and Kimi.
Final Thoughts
This isnāt just a fight between two companiesāitās a glimpse into the future of AI. Will innovation thrive in an open, competitive world? Or will lawsuits and accusations slow progress? One thingās clear: the AI wars are getting spicy, and weāre all just spectators.
What do you think? Is DeepSeek a cheater or a genius? Should OpenAI answer for its own data practices?
This blog post uses simple language, avoids jargon, and breaks down complex ideas into bite-sized sections. Let me know if youād like to expand any part further! š
About the Author

Avisek Ray
I am a skilled full-stack developer with expertise in Python (Django, FastAPI) and JavaScript (Next.js, React). With over a year of experience, Iāve delivered scalable web applications, including a news website and an AI-powered project planner. I focus on creating secure, high-performance solutions while continually expanding my skills in SQLAlchemy, Docker, and advanced Python practices. Driven by curiosity and a passion for problem-solving, I aim to build impactful, innovative applications